Referendum #11 · whitelisted caller · fact-checked
Raise the nomination-pool member limit after wrong-track cancellation
Original title: [Whitelisted Caller] Referendum #11: Set nomination pools config
Governance: Executed · Dispatch succeeded
Submitted 2023-12-13T20:43:39.000Z · 2023-12-15T03:19:51.000Z
Verification date in this record: 2026-10-14. This is not a live chain status check.
What this referendum means
What was proposed?
This referendum successfully executed the nomination-pool configuration that #9 had proposed on the wrong track.
Why it mattered
The higher ceiling allowed a single nomination pool to serve many more members, while the commission field constrained pool-operator charges.
An Aye vote meant…
An Aye vote supported raising the per-pool member limit to 50,000 and writing the raw commission value.
A Nay vote meant…
A Nay vote opposed those settings.
What happened or is happening
The proposal hash and decoded call match cancelled referendum #9. Raw Perbill value 10 equals 0.000001%, not 10%; #12 subsequently set the field to 100,000,000, or 10%.
The whitelisted nominationPools.setConfigs dispatch returned success.
Set maxMembersPerPool to 50,000 and globalMaxCommission to raw Perbill value 10, leaving every other nomination-pool setting unchanged.
No separate off-chain action was encoded.
Observable on-chain result
Dispatch returned success.
The whitelisted nominationPools.setConfigs dispatch returned success.
Promised outcomes
- Set maxMembersPerPool to 50,000.
- Set globalMaxCommission to raw Perbill value 10.
Verified outcomes
- The dispatch returned success for the encoded setConfigs call.
Follow-up: verified-complete
- Percentages are derived from the encoded Perbill denominator rather than inferred from proposal wording.
Still unknown
- The surviving proposal record does not explain whether the extremely small commission value was intentional or a scaling error.
Further explanation and reporting
No additional reporting has been published for this referendum.
Details and evidence
Participation
Participation
Calculation status: complete. Address-level figures are not counts of distinct people or organizations.
- Individual vote rows reconcile to the aggregate capital total. Concentration treats delegated capital as controlled by the account casting the direct vote.
| Direct addresses | 16 |
|---|---|
| Delegating addresses | 0 |
| Raw capital (VARA) | 1238497475 |
| Weighted Aye power (VARA) | 123854247.5 |
| Weighted Nay power (VARA) | 0 |
| Approval (%) | 100 |
| Raw capital / captured electorate (%) | 12.38496998 |
| Support capital (VARA) | 1238497475 |
| Top-one share (%) | 12.43798 |
| Top-three share (%) | 37.31395 |
| HHI (0–10,000) | 916.47426 |
| Gini (0–1) | 0.33302765 |
Proposal history
Proposal history
| Referendum | Governance | Execution | Direct addresses |
|---|---|---|---|
| #9 Cancelled wrong-track proposal to raise the pool member limit This untitled proposal would have raised the per-pool member ceiling to 50,000 while retaining the raw commission value of 10, but referendum #10 cancelled it for using the wrong track. | Cancelled | Not executed | 2 |
Timeline
Timeline
- Submitted · 2023-12-13T20:43:39.000Z · block 7636308
- DecisionDepositPlaced · 2023-12-13T20:43:51.000Z · block 7636312
- DecisionStarted · 2023-12-13T21:13:39.000Z · block 7636908
- ConfirmStarted · 2023-12-15T02:59:51.001Z · block 7672631
- Confirmed · 2023-12-15T03:09:51.000Z · block 7672831
- Executed · 2023-12-15T03:19:51.000Z · block 7673031
Technical call tree
Technical call tree
The proposal hash and decoded call match cancelled referendum #9. Raw Perbill value 10 equals 0.000001%, not 10%; #12 subsequently set the field to 100,000,000, or 10%.
{
"call": {
"callIndex": "0x1503",
"section": "whitelist",
"method": "dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage",
"args": [
{
"name": "call",
"type": "Call",
"value": {
"callIndex": "0x1f0b",
"section": "nominationPools",
"method": "setConfigs",
"args": [
{
"name": "minJoinBond",
"type": "PalletNominationPoolsConfigOpU128",
"value": {
"noop": null
}
},
{
"name": "minCreateBond",
"type": "PalletNominationPoolsConfigOpU128",
"value": {
"noop": null
}
},
{
"name": "maxPools",
"type": "PalletNominationPoolsConfigOpU32",
"value": {
"noop": null
}
},
{
"name": "maxMembers",
"type": "PalletNominationPoolsConfigOpU32",
"value": {
"noop": null
}
},
{
"name": "maxMembersPerPool",
"type": "PalletNominationPoolsConfigOpU32",
"value": {
"set": 50000
}
},
{
"name": "globalMaxCommission",
"type": "PalletNominationPoolsConfigOpPerbill",
"value": {
"set": 10
}
}
]
}
}
]
},
"nestedCalls": [
{
"depth": 0,
"callIndex": "0x1503",
"section": "whitelist",
"method": "dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"
},
{
"depth": 1,
"callIndex": "0x1f0b",
"section": "nominationPools",
"method": "setConfigs"
}
],
"limitations": []
}Historical track parameters
Historical track parameters
{
"maxDeciding": 100,
"preparePeriodBlocks": 600,
"decisionPeriodBlocks": 403200,
"confirmationPeriodBlocks": 200,
"minimumEnactmentBlocks": 200,
"decisionDeposit": {
"planck": "500000000000000000",
"vara": "500000"
},
"approvalCurve": {
"reciprocal": {
"factor": 270899180,
"xOffset": 389830523,
"yOffset": 305084738
}
},
"supportCurve": {
"reciprocal": {
"factor": 8650766,
"xOffset": 18867926,
"yOffset": 41509433
}
}
}Deposits
Deposits
Governance deposits are not proposal spending.
{
"submission": {
"depositor": "kGgQqLXhVVMv85XDy1v5AE6HVBG1tkAwURrdmq1ewbmGMCaGH",
"amount": {
"planck": "500000000000000",
"vara": "500"
}
},
"decision": {
"depositor": "kGhAjUA3Uke6UmWwMRRwFHuxisCgm7dab61sL1tKqA15NXQVX",
"amount": {
"planck": "500000000000000000",
"vara": "500000"
}
},
"outcome": "unknown"
}Sources
Sources
Corrections
Corrections
No corrections recorded.